What to Eat in New York City

New York City is great and I absolutely love it (but you knew that already). And as we are preparing for another trip to New York next week, I decided this was the perfect time to share with you my favourite food destinations in New York City. So if you are wondering what to eat in New York City, this is for you.

Obviously New York has an array of delicious, cool, unusual and sometimes rather pricy restaurants. And if you are a regular on Instagram and Pinterest, I am sure you’ve seen all the pretty foods showing up in your feed. From crazy unicorn shakes to flower shaped ice-cream, pink lattes and weird burgers.

But whilst these for sure are all great and the perfect addition to your Instagram grid, this is not the food I am talking about (doesn’t mean I wouldn’t try some of it if I happen to come by). What I am talking about are my personal favourite foods in New York City. Tried, tested and approved by Mr T and I over several trips to New York (and all paid for with our own money, so whilst this is advertising by mentioning the places, I did not receive any payment or even freebies for said mentioning).

What to eat in New York City: Cheesecake at Magnolia Bakery

(various locations, our favourite is the one in the food court of Grand Central Terminal)

Whilst Magnolia Bakery might be best known for their cupcakes, our absolute favourite is their cheesecake. With 7$ each it is not exactly cheap, but worth every cent and you can easily share one between two (don’t be fooled by the size, they really are quite rich and filling).

If you aren’t really into cheesecake, go for the banana pudding instead. Whilst it took us a while to warm to it, it is now a 50/50 chance whether we’ll go for a cheesecake or banana pudding.

What to eat in New York - Travel for a Living What to eat in New York - Travel for a Living

 

If you have a sweet tooth, head over to ‘Girl with the Passport’ for Kelly’s ‘20 Best Dessert Places in New York City‘ (well 19, since we both recommend Magnolia Bakery … shows you just how yummy their cheesecakes are). Believe me, it’s well worth it.

What to eat in New York City: Katz’s Delicatessen

(205 E Houston St)

I’ve mentioned Katz’s Delicatessen before (Top Five Things to do in NYC), but I can only repeat myself. Go and check it out. Mr T loves their Pastrami sandwich (I am sure he occasionally dreams of it) and I can absolutely recommend their cheese steak (whilst it is very tasty, I am not much of a Pastrami sandwich kinda girl).

What to eat in New York City: Pick-a-Bagel

77th Street / Lexington Ave (there are other locations, but this is our favourite)

What would New York be without its bagels? One of our favourite spots for breakfast or lunch and a staple on each and every trip so far. They have a great selection of bagels and toppings. Our favourite is plain and simple cream cheese or chicken salad. As these bagels are proper deep filled, my advice would be to purchase one with filling and one plain and then share the filling between both bagels. Saves you some money and there is still more than enough spread on each.

 Best Bagel in New York - Travel for a Living

What to eat in New York City: Hot Dog from Nathan’s

When it comes to street food, the hot dog surely is one of New York’s classics.

Nathan’s has been around for 100 years and you can spot their bright yellow stalls all around Manhattan. If you prefer eating whilst seated, head down to Coney Island for their restaurant on the board walk.

Street Food in New York - Travel for a Living Best Hot Dog in New York - Best food in New York - Travel for a Living

What to eat in New York City: Meatballs at The Meatball Shop

(several locations, we went to 200 9th Avenue)

We’ve only recently discovered this restaurant and what shall I say. It pretty much does what it says on the tin. It sells meatballs. I don’t know if they are the best meatballs in New York, but they surely are rather tasty.

To place your order you get a laminated menu and a wipe clean pen and you just tick everything you want and hand the menu back to your waitress.

What to eat in New York City: Pizza Slice at 2Bros Pizza

(several locations, we went to the one on the corner 8th Avenue / W 38th Street)

With every trip to New York we discover new places to eat. During our most recent trip, we came across 2Bros Pizza. And whilst a pizza slice is one of those things every New York guide book recommends, somehow we’ve never had one. Probably a mistake. You can find pizza by the slice all over New York and prices can vary hugely. But this One Dollar Slice from 2Bros Pizza was enormous, cheap and rather tasty. And when I say 1$, I really mean it (as this already included sales tax for once). So perfect, in case you are visiting New York on a budget.

What to eat in New York - Travel for a Living What to eat in New York - Travel for a Living

As I said in the beginning, this is not necessarily the Ultimate Food Guide for New York City. This is merely a run down of my favourite foods there. I might add more things to this list as I visit again next week, we’ll see.

What are your favourites? Tell me your recommendations on what to eat in New York City!

What to eat in New York City - My personal favourites from Bagel to Cheesecake and everything in-between - Travel for a Liiving What to eat in New York City - Cheesecake, Hot Dogs, New York Bagels - Travel for a Living

Leave a Reply

10 Comments

  1. The Champagne Mile

    Yum, salivating reading this! A trip to NYC is on the cards next year, and I’ll be seeking out a pastrami sandwich at Katz’s Delicatessen 🙂

    Reply
    • Travel for a living

      You definitely should do. It is well worth it. I would advise trying to miss main lunch time though, it gets rather busy and their ordering system is a little chaotic.

      Reply
  2. stephanie

    OMG I loved Pick a bagel and Meatball shop! The bagels were delish and the meatballs were so unique!

    Reply
  3. Jessica Festa

    Double yes to Katz’s! My absolutely favorite for lunch 🙂

    Reply
  4. Top 5 things to do in New York City – Travel for a Living

    […] leave you starving (and wishing for a foot massage… that might just be me though). There is plenty of great food all around you, from posh restaurants to quick street food. So if you are going hungry you only have yourself to […]

    Reply
  5. Best Shopping Places in New York City - Travel for a Living

    […] I am not saying you should fly over to New York just for shopping (I am not saying it aloud, but I might whisper it into your ear), but IF you happen to be in New York for sightseeing, it would be rude not to schedule in some shopping time as well. Wouldn’t you agree? I mean after all it is part of the ultimate New York City experience. Along with all the great food New York has to offer. […]

    Reply
  6. Our Trip to San Francisco - Part Two - Travel for a Living

    […] to the Meatball Shop in New York before, which we loved (and which actually made it onto my list of Top 5 Eats in New York City), so expectations were high. And what shall I say? We weren’t […]

    Reply
  7. You've got Mail Movie Locations Tour NYC - Travel for a Living

    […] This hot dog shop has featured in many movies and TV series over the years. And apparently these are some of the best hot dogs you can get in New York. Unfortunately, I cannot vouch for it. Since we didn’t have any cash on us when we visited (and it turned out the credit card / Apple pay sticker on the door was just for decoration, as inside it said ‘cash only’). Therefore, as far as I am concerned, I stick to Nathan’s as my New York favourite hot dog. […]

    Reply
  8. Visiting Brooklyn - Dekalb Market Hall - Travel for a Living

    […] Kebap, Brooklyn Bagels, Katz’s Pastrami on Rye (the only stall they have in addition to their main restaurant down on Houston Street), Crêpes (although I have to say they didn’t look anything like traditional French crêpes, […]

    Reply
  9. Movie Location Tour New York City for free - Travel for a Living

    […] Magnolia Bakery all over New York (and if you have a sweet tooth, I would very much urge you to go and visit at least one for their cheesecakes and banana puddings), but this one on the corner of Beeker Street and West 11th Street was the very first one. And […]

    Reply